Free. Confidential. No citations, no penalties. That is how the OSHA consultation program (officially On-Site Consultation) gets sold, and the pitch is accurate as far as it goes. A state consultant walks your site, tells you what OSHA would cite, writes it up, and sends you no bill. For a fifteen-person fabrication shop that has never written a safety program, it is the best value in American occupational safety, and it is not close.
Then there is the half of the deal that gets one line in the brochure and most of a section in the regulation. You agree to fix what they find. Not consider fixing. Agree — on dates, in writing, with a hazard list posted where your crew reads it, and with a referral to enforcement waiting at the far end if those dates slip. Most companies that get surprised by this program were never told the second half out loud. It is also where the state program and private OSHA compliance consulting part ways.
What the OSHA consultation program is underneath the brochure
Part 1908 rests on sections 21(c) and 21(d) of the OSH Act, and 21(d) is the newer half — added by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration Compliance Assistance Authorization Act of 1998 (Pub. L. 105–197, enacted July 16, 1998), which directed the Secretary to establish cooperative agreements under which employers consult with state personnel about applying and complying with OSHA requirements (29 CFR 1908.1(a)). The operating rules live in 29 CFR Part 1908, whose full text sits on govinfo.gov for anyone who wants to check a paragraph against what a brochure says about it. Read that part once and most of the marketing questions answer themselves.
The Cooperative Agreement runs between the Assistant Secretary and a state — the Governor, or a state agency the Governor designates (29 CFR 1908.10(a)) — and OSHA reimburses 90 percent of the costs incurred under it (29 CFR 1908.3(b)(1)). OSHA describes the consultants who actually show up as coming from state agencies or universities. None of them are OSHA compliance officers. The consultative activity has its own identifiable managerial staff, and in State Plan states that staff is separate from the people who manage compliance inspections and scheduling (29 CFR 1908.7(a)(2)). The wall is real. It is also narrower than most people assume.
Two structural facts shape everything else. A visit happens only at the employer’s request and cannot result from the enforcement of any right of entry under state law (29 CFR 1908.5(b)(1)) — nobody shows up uninvited. And “employer” under Part 1908 means a person engaged in a business who has employees, excluding the United States — the Postal Service excepted — and any state or political subdivision of a state (29 CFR 1908.2), with reimbursement limited to consultation provided to private sector employers (29 CFR 1908.3(b)(2)). If you are a city, a county, a school district, or a federal installation, the 21(d) service is not yours to request. Some State Plan states run their own public-sector consultation under state authority; that is a different program with different rules, and you have to ask your state whether it exists.
How a visit actually runs
An initial visit is an opening conference, an examination of the parts of your safety and health program that relate to the scope of the request, a walkthrough, and a closing conference, followed by a written report (29 CFR 1908.6(b)). The opening conference is where the terms get stated, and it is the meeting people show up late to. The consultant is required to explain the relationship between onsite consultation and OSHA enforcement activity, explain your obligation to protect employees if certain hazardous conditions turn up, and emphasize your obligation to post the List of Hazards that accompanies the report (29 CFR 1908.6(d)(2)). Everything unpleasant that happens later was disclosed in that room.
Employee participation is not optional garnish. The consultant keeps the right to confer with individual employees, and you must agree to permit that contact before the visit can proceed (29 CFR 1908.6(c)(1)). An employee representative must also be given the opportunity to accompany the consultant and your representative through the workplace (29 CFR 1908.6(c)(2)(i)). If your crew is going to tell a stranger what really happens on second shift, decide now whether that is a problem you want found by a consultant or by a compliance officer.
Two documents come out of the visit, and confusing them is the most common mistake employers make. The written report goes to you, and the state may not disclose it to anyone else except as Part 1908 allows (29 CFR 1908.6(g)(2)). The List of Hazards is a separate thing, defined at 29 CFR 1908.2 as a list of all serious hazards the consultant identified together with the correction due dates you and the consultant agreed on. The report is yours. The list goes on the wall.
The same definitions section carries a line that changes how you should read the whole visit. A serious hazard under Part 1908 is any condition or practice that would be classified as a serious violation under the applicable standards, except that the element of employer knowledge shall not be considered. In an enforcement case, knowledge is something the agency has to establish. Here it is switched off. A hazard nobody in management had reason to know about still lands on the list, still gets a due date, and still gets posted.
The correction agreement is the part nobody reads
When the consultant determines a serious hazard exists, they help you build a specific plan to correct it and give you a reasonable period to do the work. If you disagree with a timeframe or any other substantive finding, you have a window: the state must provide a prompt opportunity for informal discussion with the consultation manager if you request it within 15 working days of receiving the consultant’s report. Both the plan and the window are in the same paragraph, 29 CFR 1908.6(e)(7). Use the window. It closes quietly.
As a condition of receiving the service, you must post the List of Hazards unedited, in a prominent place readily observable by all affected employees, for three working days or until the hazards are corrected, whichever is later (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(8)). Unedited. A copy goes to the employee representative who participated, and information on proposed corrective actions and on other-than-serious hazards has to be available at the worksite for employee review.
Posting an unedited list of your own serious hazards where the whole crew can read it sounds like an invitation to a complaint, and the rule anticipates that: OSHA will not schedule a compliance inspection in response to a complaint based on a posted List of Hazards unless you fail to meet your obligations under paragraph (f) or fail to provide interim protection for exposed employees (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(8)). That is the hinge. Everything downstream turns on whether you do the work.
- Imminent danger. You must act immediately. If you do not, the consultant must immediately notify the affected employees and the appropriate OSHA enforcement authority (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(1)). No grace period.
- Serious hazards. You must act under the agreed plan and meet the posting requirement. To show the work is happening you may be required to submit periodic reports or permit a follow-up visit (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(2)).
- Extensions. Conditional on three showings: good faith effort within the original timeframe, factors beyond your reasonable control, and all available interim steps to safeguard employees during the correction period (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(3)).
- Failure to correct. Miss the timeframe or an approved extension and the consultation manager shall immediately notify OSHA enforcement, which decides whether activity is warranted (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(4)).
- Closeout. After correcting all serious hazards you confirm the corrections in writing, unless the consultant verified them by direct observation (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(5)).
None of that is unreasonable. It is a commitment with a schedule and a counterparty. Do not request a visit you are not prepared and funded to act on within the next quarter.
Confidential from whom
What the rule protects: the identity of employers requesting onsite consultation, and the file of the consultant’s visit, shall not be provided to OSHA for use in any compliance activity — with four named exceptions (29 CFR 1908.7(a)(3)). Failure to eliminate an imminent danger. Failure to eliminate serious hazards. Inspection deferral. Participation in the recognition and exemption program. Two of those four are doors you opened on purpose. The other two are failures.
What the rule does not do:
- It does not hide you administratively. The state shall provide consultation program information requested by OSHA, including information identifying employers who requested services, for administering and evaluating the program — treated as exempt from public disclosure to the maximum extent permitted by law (29 CFR 1908.6(h)(2)).
- It is not a legal privilege. Nothing in Part 1908 creates attorney-client privilege or work-product protection. It binds the state; it does not follow the document into a civil suit, a client contract audit, or a prequalification questionnaire.
- It does not survive a bad-faith finding. You need not tell a later compliance officer about the visit or hand over the report. But if OSHA independently develops reason to believe you failed to correct identified serious hazards, recreated the same hazard, or made false statements in connection with the program, it may exercise its authority to obtain the consultation report (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(3)).
- It creates no citation defense. The consultant’s advice is not binding on a compliance officer, and the consultant’s failure to point out a specific hazard does not constitute a defense to any enforcement action (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(1) and (c)(2)). “The state consultant walked this line and said nothing” is a sentence you will say once.
There is a real upside on the enforcement side, and it runs on your initiative. If you choose to give a compliance officer a copy of the report, it may be used as a factor in how far the inspection goes and in proposed penalties. And where a compliance officer finds a serious hazard the consultant had already flagged, the Area Director has authority to assess minimum penalties if you are in good faith complying with the consultant’s recommendations (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(4)). Good faith in progress helps. A finished list you ignored does the opposite.
Free program or paid consultant: what each is actually for
| Question | OSHA On-Site Consultation (21(d)) | Private consultant |
|---|---|---|
| Who can use it | Private-sector employers only; government bodies excluded by 29 CFR 1908.2 | Anyone, including public agencies and federal contractors |
| Scheduling control | Priority to the most hazardous operations, primary attention to smaller businesses (29 CFR 1908.5(c)) | You set the date |
| Hazards outside your requested scope | Must be treated as though within scope (29 CFR 1908.5(b)(2)) | Scope is contractual and stays where you put it |
| Obligation the findings create | Binding correction agreement with due dates, posting, and referral on failure | A report; the correction duty is your existing statutory one |
| Who else sees the findings | Your employees, unedited, on the wall; the state; OSHA in four named circumstances | Whoever you send it to |
| Citation defense value | Expressly none (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(2)) | None either — but the abatement record is yours to build |
| Your written programs | Review and advice within scope (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(3)) | Authorship and revision of the documents themselves |
| Contract deliverables (SSSP, EM 385-1-1 APP, prequalification) | Not a service of the program | Routine work |
| Help abating an existing citation | Only once 29 CFR 1908.7(b)(3) is satisfied, and only for items that became final orders | Immediately |
| Formal recognition | SHARP, with a real exemption from programmed inspections | None to offer |
That is a division of labor, not a scorecard. The free program is genuinely better at what it was built for and structurally unable to do several things a commercial contract does routinely, which is why we scope OSHA compliance consulting engagements around the state programs rather than against them.
The limited-scope request that does not stay limited
Employers who are nervous about the program invent the same workaround. Request a narrow visit. Just the lockout program. Just the paint booth. Keep the consultant away from the mezzanine.
The regulation closed that door before you thought of it. You may specify a limited scope by naming working conditions, hazards, or situations to focus on — but if the consultant observes hazards outside that scope during the visit, the consultant must treat them as though they were within the scope of the request (29 CFR 1908.5(b)(2)). Where a scope is reduced, the consultant remains obligated to work with you to ensure correction of the serious hazards identified (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(1)).
A narrow request narrows what they go looking for. It does not narrow what they are allowed to see, and it does not narrow what you now owe. If something on your site would be painful on a posted list with a due date attached, find it yourself first. That is what a private OSHA compliance audit and gap analysis is for.
Written programs: review is not authorship
This is where most of the disappointment lands. An employer asks the state to help with their safety programs, expects documents, and receives feedback on documents that do not exist yet.
The rule says consultants shall review the employer’s safety and health program and provide advice on modifications or additions to make it more effective (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(3)). Review. Advise. That is a valuable service — a good consultant will tell you your energy control procedures are generic, your PPE hazard assessment was never certified, and your permit program names a rescue service that does not know it is your rescue service. What they will not do is produce your machine-specific lockout/tagout procedures, your written hazard communication program, or your permit-required confined space program as deliverables with your logo on them.
Start with trigger logic rather than a template — which written safety programs OSHA actually requires walks the standard-by-standard version. Then decide whether you are having written safety programs developed for you or drafting them in-house and using the state visit as free peer review. Both are defensible. Confusing the two costs you a year.
The same limit applies to contract paperwork. Nothing makes this program a source for a site-specific safety plan a general contractor demands before mobilization, an accident prevention plan built to EM 385-1-1, or the credentialed site safety and health officer a federal contract names. Those obligations come from a contract, not from 29 CFR.
SHARP: the payoff and the price of admission
Recognition is the reason to treat consultation as a strategy rather than a one-time favor. Part 1908 describes the recognition and exemption program as providing incentives and support to smaller, high-hazard employers to develop, implement, and continuously improve a safety and health management system (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(4)). Everyone calls it SHARP.
It runs in two stages. Programmed inspections can be deferred while you are working toward recognition — the status usually called Pre-SHARP — and an employer who meets every requirement has the establishment removed from OSHA’s programmed inspection schedule for a period of not less than one year from issuance of the certificate (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(4)(i)(B)). One year is the floor in the regulation, not the number you will be quoted. Certification and renewal terms are set by OSHA policy and administered through the state programs, and they have moved over the years. Get the current term from your state consultation office in writing before you build a plan around it.
Here is what the regulation itself conditions the deferral on, and it is the same ledger you are eventually judged against for the certificate.
| What 29 CFR 1908.7(b)(4)(i)(A) requires | What that means on the ground |
|---|---|
| You request participation | Nobody nominates you. It is an application, and the clock starts when you file it |
| A visit covering all conditions and operations related to safety and health | Full scope, safety and health both. The narrow request is off the table by definition |
| All hazards identified are corrected within established time frames | All of them, on dates already agreed — not the ones you found convenient |
| The elements of an effective safety and health program are being implemented | Operating, with evidence. A written program nobody runs does not read as implementation |
| You agree to request further consultation when major changes introduce new hazards | A standing obligation that outlives the certificate. New line, new process, new building — you call |
Read the next part twice before you apply. When you request consideration for the recognition and exemption program, the correction-plan, posting, extension, and written-confirmation provisions apply to other-than-serious hazards as well as serious ones (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(5)). Outside the program, other-than-serious findings are advice you can weigh. Inside it, they carry due dates and a posting obligation. That single sentence is why some employers who would sail through on serious hazards stall out.
Part 1908 is not the whole gate. OSHA layers its own eligibility screens on top — employer size, industry hazard profile, whether the operation sits at a fixed site, and injury and illness rate history measured against industry averages — and those criteria live in agency policy rather than in the CFR, which is exactly why the thresholds you read on a third-party page may be out of date. Ask the state office for the current criteria and the current rate benchmark before you spend a year chasing it.
Recognition is not amnesty either. OSHA continues to inspect SHARP and deferral sites for imminent danger, fatality and catastrophe, and formal complaints (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(4)(ii)), and a Cooperative Agreement does not restrict the Assistant Secretary’s authority and responsibility under sections 8, 9, 10, 13, and 17 of the Act — inspections, citations, contests, injunctions, penalties (29 CFR 1908.11). If your safety program elements amount to a binder and a toolbox talk, you are not approaching SHARP. You are approaching the point where you could start.
The sequence that works
The expensive mistake is calling the state first, at a site nobody has honestly assessed, with no budget line for correction. The clock then starts on what they find, on their classification, on dates negotiated in a closing conference you walked into cold. Invert it.
- Find your own hazards on a schedule you control. A private walk produces a list with no posting obligation, no due dates filed with a state agency, and no referral pathway.
- Fix the obvious and the embarrassing. Guarding, energy control, egress, electrical, chemical labeling. What would have become serious classifications are now closed items.
- Write the programs the standards oblige you to have, matched to the work rather than to a template.
- Then invite the state in with a full-scope request, because full scope is now an asset rather than an exposure. This is also the entry point for Pre-SHARP.
- Keep a private cadence between visits. A mock OSHA inspection run the way a real inspection runs tells you whether the program survives contact with a Tuesday.
If the difference between an audit, a gap analysis, and a mock inspection is fuzzy, it matters more than the vocabulary suggests — which one you are actually buying sorts it out, and what happens in a mock OSHA inspection covers the day itself.
When the free program is the wrong tool
- You already have a citation. Consultation cannot begin while an enforcement inspection is in progress, and afterward only once no citation will issue or as to items that became final orders (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(3), 1908.5(b)(3)). Abatement and contest deadlines do not wait — see what to do when you receive an OSHA citation.
- A contract, not a standard, is driving the requirement. Prequalification portals, owner safety manuals, and EM 385-1-1 accident prevention plans sit outside the program’s remit.
- You need a person on site, not a visit. When the exposure is continuous supervision, you are looking for a full-time safety professional on the project.
- You are a public entity. The definition of employer at 29 CFR 1908.2 settles it, whatever a state-run public-sector program may offer alongside.
- The timing is not yours to lose. Priority goes to smaller businesses with the most hazardous operations (29 CFR 1908.5(c)). If your deadline is a mobilization date, buy the date.
- You are a multi-site company. Consultation is site-by-site and availability differs across states, which is why our state-by-state consulting coverage exists.
Use the free program where it is strongest: a stable single site with real appetite for a management system and a year of runway. Buy help where the constraint is a deadline, a contract, an open enforcement action, or a document that has to carry your name.
Common questions
Is the OSHA on-site consultation program really free?
Yes, in the sense that matters at your end: there is no charge to the employer. The Assistant Secretary reimburses 90 percent of the costs incurred under the Cooperative Agreement, with approved training of state staff and specified out-of-state travel reimbursed in full, and state funds cover the balance (29 CFR 1908.3(b)(1), 1908.5(a)(3)). The cost to plan for is the correction work, which is neither free nor optional once you have agreed to a date.
Will OSHA cite me during a consultation visit?
No. The consultant does not issue citations or propose penalties, and identifying a hazard does not mandate either. What it does mandate is your agreement to correct imminent dangers immediately and serious hazards within a reasonable time (29 CFR 1908.5(a)(3)).
Does the consultation program report me to OSHA enforcement?
Not routinely. Your identity and the visit file are not provided to OSHA for use in any compliance activity except in four circumstances: failure to eliminate an imminent danger, failure to eliminate serious hazards, inspection deferral, and participation in the recognition and exemption program (29 CFR 1908.7(a)(3)).
What happens if I do not fix what the consultant finds?
For an imminent danger you do not address immediately, the consultant must notify affected employees and the OSHA enforcement authority right away (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(1)). For a serious hazard not corrected within the agreed timeframe or an approved extension, the consultation manager shall immediately notify enforcement, which then decides whether activity is warranted (29 CFR 1908.6(f)(4)).
Do I have to post the list of hazards where employees can see it?
Yes, and unedited. You must post the List of Hazards in a prominent place readily observable by all affected employees for three working days or until the hazards are corrected, whichever is later, and notify employees when hazards are corrected (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(8)).
Can I ask the consultant to look at only one area?
You can limit the scope of the request. You cannot limit what the consultant must do with what they see: hazards observed outside the requested scope are treated as though they were within it (29 CFR 1908.5(b)(2)).
Am I exempt from OSHA inspections if I use the consultation program?
Not by using it. Exemption from programmed inspections comes with SHARP certification, for a period of not less than one year from issuance of the certificate (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(4)(i)(B)), with deferral available while you work toward it. Imminent danger, fatality and catastrophe, and formal complaint inspections continue regardless (29 CFR 1908.7(b)(4)(ii)).
How long does it take to get a consultation visit?
That depends on your state’s queue. Priority is assigned to businesses with the most hazardous operations, with primary attention to smaller businesses (29 CFR 1908.5(c)). A larger, lower-hazard employer with a contractual deadline should not plan around a date it does not control.
Can I use the consultation program to help fix an OSHA citation?
You may request onsite consultation to assist with abating cited hazards, but not while an enforcement inspection is in progress, and afterward only once it is determined that no citation will be issued or, if one was, as to items that have become final orders (29 CFR 1908.5(b)(3), 1908.7(b)(3)).
Will the consultation program write my written safety programs for me?
No. Within the scope of your request, consultants review your safety and health program and advise on modifications or additions to make it more effective (29 CFR 1908.6(e)(3)). Authorship, revision control, and site-specific drafting stay with you or your consultant.
Is the consultation report protected by attorney-client privilege?
No. Part 1908 restricts what the state may disclose; it does not create a privilege, and OSHA may obtain the report where it independently develops reason to believe you failed to correct identified serious hazards, recreated the same hazard, or made false statements in connection with the program (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(3)). If litigation exposure is the concern, structure the engagement with counsel before anyone writes anything down.
Does having used the program help me if I am inspected later?
It can, on your initiative. If you choose to give a compliance officer a copy of the report, it may be considered in determining the extent of the inspection and in proposed penalties, and the Area Director may assess minimum penalties where you are in good faith complying with the consultant’s recommendations (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(4)). The consultant’s silence about a hazard, by contrast, is expressly not a defense (29 CFR 1908.7(c)(2)).
The short version
The program trades information for commitment. You get a professional walk of your site and a written evaluation at no cost. You give up control of the correction schedule, accept a posting obligation your workforce will read, and open a referral path that opens only if you fail. For the right employer that is an excellent trade and the on-ramp to SHARP. It is the wrong trade when a deadline, a contract, an open citation, or a deliverable is the actual problem.
Those are purchases, not favors. If you are working out which situation you are in, tell us what you are up against and we will say plainly when to call the state instead — and when paid OSHA compliance support is the faster and cheaper answer.
About the Author
Patrick Salazar — founder of 3P Safety and an OSHA 500 authorized construction outreach trainer, working NCCCO-certified mobile crane operator (LBC, TLL, TSS), tower crane operator, certified crane inspector, and lift director. In the field since 2005, advising employers on safety programs, OSHA compliance, and audit-ready documentation nationwide.

